Another good butter lipgloss. The color is a medium pink but seems to have a purple tintish undertone. Because of that it's not a gloss I can put on every day. But still pretty. As with all the butter glosses they don't stay put very long and need to be reapplied often.

I've had 5 shades of the original butter gloss: this, Tiramisu (my absolute fave), Red Velvet, Devil's Food Cake, and Blackberry Pie. AFC is described as a mauve, but it pulls more pink on me. I was a little disappointed because I'm not a huge fan of straight-up pink lip products, but mauves are a staple in my collection. I've noticed that NYX's shade descriptions aren't exactly on point. What is on point, however, is the quality of this gloss. I've reviewed Butter Glosses in general, so I've already expressed my undying love for these little cosmetic treasures, but I feel like I need to do AFC some justice. Even though it's so obviously pink on me with not a hint of mauve to be found, this is a very flattering colour on my NC10-NC15 skin tone. Not over-the-top pink, but enough to add some life to my face when my chronic illness flares up and I don't have the energy to do a full face of makeup. It's ridiculous how much livelier I look when I swipe a couple coats of this onto my lips. I wouldn't say this is an MLBB shade for me, but it's very natural looking without being unnoticeable. Butter glosses tend to last an hour or so on me, which isn't a big deal as I love reapplying them and they're easy to apply without a mirror. If you have a light and cool skin tone, this will be a nice pop of natural colour to your face. If AFC doesn't work for you, NYX has about 30 something other shades of this stellar little gloss, so you're covered.
-Ny

This product was fine. I usually like more of a sheer MLB(way)B cranberry red but noticed that a sort of browned pink looks the most natural and flattering on me after trying Maybelline Lover. I will also say that SO commented several times that this is his favorite lip shade on me. That said, it isn't for me because it doesn't last long enough. With very occasional wear, I went through a tube in 3 months. It wears off very easily, and I understand that it markets itself as a "butter gloss," so I'm not necessarily taking points off for this, but for my personal preferences this was too glossy. I also don't enjoy the super sweet frosting scent, though I'm not usually opposed to scents. I would recommend this to those who want a sheer, MLBB, glossy, moisturizing product and are fine with frequent re-application and transfer as well as a very sweet frosting scent. I am NC20 and can see how this is flattering on my skintone, even if it's not necessarily my makeup "style." I'd say that this probably wouldn't show up on pigmented lips.

This is a nice pink gloss. I was expecting it to be a little darker because the tube is darker than the other 2 pinks I purchased in this line (Vanilla Cream Pie and Eclair). I think this looks similar to Vanilla Cream Pie. I would probably pick one or the other if I was going to repurchase. I've uploaded a picture so you can see the color.

People love this stuff, did I get a dud? Mine was dry and the applicator seemed to deposit no product unless I really dug in the tube. Not a fan.