Disappointed because I usually love NYX products! Bought this in chocolate brown. Loved the colour when I tested it on my hand. Once I tried it on my lids it was hard to make a consistent line and it dried patchy and sheer as if it were dried out. Packaging is also terrible.. cannot take in my bag without the lid coming off. Won't buy again.

I have this in 02 Dark Brown. I have been searching for a lower-cost alternative to my hg felt tip liner, Stila Stay All Day. This one is fine, but not as good as the Stila version. Stila's works better for my hooded lids because the tip is much narrower, allowing for more precise application. Other than that, they are very similar products though I do think Stila lasts a smidge longer on me than the NYX. Overall this is a good but not great product, but offers good value for the price.

This is the worst felt tip liner I've ever used. It says extreme black on it but barely comes out light grey. Scratchy too. Hate it!

I purchased the NYX Colored Felt Tip Liner in Grey because it was the only gray I could find. Every other gray was too shiny or silvery or full of glitter. This NYX is just gray a mid-dark gray. Its very easy to use because the felt tip makes a thin line with no feathering. I loved everything about this liner until I discovered it is not water resistant. Even after it sets, it is not water resistent. At least it doesnt smudge. It just disappears. I didn't expect it to be waterproof, but for ten dollars I expected to be able to get half a day out of it.This Colored Felt Tip Liner might be good to use if you are testing out different looks. You could remove it easily and just start again. But you couldn't rely on this for everyday wear.You can find a photo of this athttp://www.nyxcosmetics.com/colored-felt-tip-liner/NYX_307.htmlFor some reason, I am not able to add a photo or link, it just says 'loading, loading'