I love these eye shadow pencils!!!!!!!!! This is the first one of these I've gotten. It goes on very smoothly and is highly pigmented. When I got it I thought that I was buying the nyx eye shadow pencil in milk. For the first week that I had it I thought that it was the one in milk. The cottage cheese color is really good though. I guess that there is probably not that muc of a difference between the two colors. The milk shade is probably more a stark white while the cottage cheese color is more an off white I think. I also want to buy a few more colors. The rusty, lavender, bronze, and the turquoise shades.