This is the first lip liner I've tried from NYX and I love it! The formula is great, not too drying and applies easily. The color is gorgeous too, a MLBB rose shade. I love to just use this to fill in my lips and top it with some gloss. I would repurchase this and I will be buying more colors from this line.

This is a warm slightly frosty Rose tone pencil (borders on neutral . I have other NYX pencils in the neutral tones but this one seemed slightly more of a pop of color and I recently got Pop of color liquid lippy in Peony thought this would look good. It is almost a direct match. This doesn't stand out alone for me as a use alone item as my other NYX pencils do, but I will use it under this under my Pop lippy and may try it under some of my nude or buff lippys to warm up the color. All in all I do love the NYX pencils and even if this isn't a blow out of the water it has a place in my liner pencils!

This color is a warm shimmery rose. Honestly, there's nothing really remarkable about this color. It doesn't last as long as a matte shade, it doesn't prolong my lipstick, and there are other colors that I prefer in brand, like Mauve and Peekaboo Neutral. It's the first NYX Slim Lip Pencil that I've been disappointed with.Also, the color is nowhere near the same color as the NYX Citrine lipstick. Nothing about this color says Citrine. It's more of a dark brownish pink with shimmer.If you like this type of color and are looking for a lip pencil, it's worth trying. It doesn't last as long as matte shades, but that's pretty common for a shimmery lip product. If you're on the fence or already have similar lip pencils, skip this color.