I own MAC lip pencils along with NYX. Unlike other reviewers I have not experienced any drying or difficulty sharpening NYX pencils. I always moisturize my lips before applying anything to them.This color is a neutral toned pink. Perfect for when wearing a muted pink or light berry hues lip stick. Last as long as MAC,no bleeding.I find Prestige lip pencils except color Poppy(Orange) to be dry and hard to put on.Never have that issue with NYX.

A very nice medium pink shade that applies nicely and lasts a long time. I usually line my lips with this then apply a pink lipgloss on top. I love this shade.

Unlike the other reviewers here I did not experience a negative outcome with Pinky. As always I swipe my lips with Burts Bees lip balm in honey before I apply any lip colors so I did the same before applying this. Paired with my MAC Candy Yum Yum its a nice match. No bleeding, no difficulty in lining....I will be repurchasing this.

Not exactly "pink" on my lips. I'm very pale and this liner looks more like a dark rose color on me.UPDATE: I've ended up liking this lip liner best of all the ones I own. Including M.A.C. ones. It works with so many of the colors I like now. I just bought two more.

NYX lip liners are very dry and chalky. I definitely prefer Prestige's lip liners (same price range too), which are much more pigmented and easy to blend on the lip. This color is much darker on my lips that it appears in the pencil form. Not very flattering on my pale skin, and I imagine other people would be disappointed that it's not the neon pink expected.