I got this after trying the micro pencil in Chocolate and finding it ran too red for my dark brown brows. I figured with the big selection of shades including auburns, that this would really be a medium brown. Nope. This shows up as auburn brown on me. It is pretty much the same as Chocolate in the micro pencil, but with a thicker "lead" in it. Both products have the same waxy-opaque colour and texture. If the colour had worked for me, I would be happy, but unless you are looking for reddish warm tones in your brown pencil, I'd say pass on this. Of the NYX brow products I've tried, I think the only real winner for me have been the powder and the gel. I am still on the hunt for a natural looking pencil to fill in sparse areas on my otherwise unremarkable brows.