I got this after trying the micro pencil in Chocolate and finding it ran too red for my dark brown brows. I figured with the big selection of shades including auburns, that this would really be a medium brown. Nope. This shows up as auburn brown on me. It is pretty much the same as Chocolate in the micro pencil, but with a thicker "lead" in it. Both products have the same waxy-opaque colour and texture. If the colour had worked for me, I would be happy, but unless you are looking for reddish warm tones in your brown pencil, I'd say pass on this. Of the NYX brow products I've tried, I think the only real winner for me have been the powder and the gel. I am still on the hunt for a natural looking pencil to fill in sparse areas on my otherwise unremarkable brows.

This product is just.. eh. Packaging looks really cheap and plastic, so I rated it a 2/5. Also,this color has an orange undertone to it so it looks really awkward in my very dark browneyebrows. Okay pigmentation, and not hygienic packaging since there's no cap on thebrush. Wish the tip was not as thick, but I can't really complain because of it's price. Overall I wouldn't repurchase or recommend to a friend but if they don't care about their eyebrows as much as I do, it should be fine. @makeupdupe.s on instagram // helpful? Like!

100% HG product for brows. Best formula/product for brows I have ever come across. Will repurchase over and over

I wasn't impressed with this brow pencil. I was using 'define a brow' by Maybelline and I just wanted to try something different to see what else is out there. The pencil tip is what i really don't like. It doesn't have a very pointy tip so it is hard to get a defined shape that I am trying to achieve with my brow pencil. I also didn't like how the packaging is a little bit deceiving. The lid color looked a lot darker than the actual pencil color. Since it's all packaged up you can't see the actual color of the pencil so I ended up buying one that was too light for me. This product is just meh... there are way better brow pencils at the drugstore, I will not be buying this again I probably will end up throwing it out. The formula is dry and scratchy and I just don't like it.

The NYX eyebrow pencil is incredible. I bought mine in Light Brown, for $9 from Target (Australia). Light brown is perfect colour to complement my auburn hair. It's smooth and waxy, and definitely worth the money I paid. I would pay Anastasia Beverly Hills prices for this product.