I also am a fan of Whipped Caviar pink nude shade. This looked very orange-y in the tube and I was worried it was too brown/peach but I think it's a keeper. I have an Elf light pink in their $5 Bare collection that is definitely too light alone, so I put on Eurotrash and then put a little of the light pink on top, mainly in the middle of my lips. It's really nice, natural but not 'too' anything (dark, orange, light, etc.). I have a hard time with lipsticks looking perfect; I always seem to need to mix shades a little. However, I think this will be a good color when pinks or berries won't do. BTW, Walgreen's did have testers of the NYX line, which I appreciated.