First, this has a tingle, but not as much as my favorite plumper (Buxon). Also, NYC has more pigment and a stronger tingle.Second, the color is a glossy nude that matches my lips. That's a bit disappointing because I wanted more of a bronzy tint. I might have to go to a lipstick for that.Third, the consistency is tacky enough to last for a while, but you'll need to re-apply after eating/drinking.Fourth, the price is great. Buxon costs $19, and this product is close for me.I will buy again AFTER I use up all my other million sheer/nude glosses/plumpers AND if I have a good deal. If you already have a drawer full of sheers and nudes, choose a different color.UPDATE: After washing my face last night, some of product was still there. So, the staying power is oddly very high. The shine wasn't there, but it felt like I had used lip balm--like the balm was starting to wear off. Odd.