I bought this on a whim from the 75 percent off bin at my local CVS. I actually really really like the product, the brow pencil works really well and the color (taupe) is great for me. The highlighter stick is also really pretty and gives a great, subtle sheen. That being said, the packaging is so terrible that I don't know if I would buy this again, unless I could find it in the bargain bin. Every time I use it both ends get stuck in the caps and o have to fish them out. Then they usually fall on the floor and I have to stick them back in the tube before using it. I also think Nyx “gets you by putting barely any product in the packaging. There products aren't that cheap if you are getting only half the product as the more expensive brands.

For the price? This is awesome. For anyone with dark brows the ash brown color is is natural and easy to apply. It's actually ashy and not at all warm which is nice for a brow product. You get a little highlighter to put on your brow bone which is nice. I use it on the inner corner of my eye as well. Good job NYX.

Packaging not so great. Have used it 3 times and the highlight stick has fallen out once. The highlight stick is too fat and is very white. Maybe the twist up pencils are just not for me.

I bought this in a pinch while traveling because I forgot my go-to Urban Decay Brow Beater. This may just replace it! It's so much more affordable, and it lasts all day. I like the thickness and the waxy-ish texture of it. I feel like this is a good 'beginner' eyebrow pencil. It fills sparse brows in nicely without having to be super detailed.I don't really use the highlight part much I bought it primarily for the brow pencil itself. The highlight takes a bit of blending to look nice, but it has a nice subtle shimmer to it.

Firstly the product is rather pricey but of course cheaper than Anastasia Beverly Hills brow pencil. I love ABH it's just perfect but it's little and expensive. So I don't mind trying something cheaper. I bought Nyx brow on impulse because of the highlight actually instead of using a concealer to highlight. I use ABH pencil to mark my brow then I use the Nyx (medium) to fill up. It's thick and creamy but I use it very lightly. It's a bit dark but I use Nyx brow tinted brow gel afterwards so it's perfect. But when I wanted to use the highlighter it broke almost immediately! It comes with a sharpener so I sharpen it up and highlight under my brow. It's creamy! Today I wanted to use it without adding any powder highlighter and now after 12 hours. My brow stays so as the highlighter! Honestly I am considering to get the light colour and I would definitely recommend if anyone doesn't mind a bit work and time doing the brow. Or else this might not be a good buy.