I have a huge collection of NYX eye/eyebrow pencis and lipliners.They're uber cheap for $1.50, good pigmentation and fair durability.I love the texture, it can be used as kohl (waterline) and for eyebrows too. Because it is creamy, I use it to quick contour my nose and jaw as well, smudged with my fingers.MIght not be for those with oily lids and oily skin, but for dry skin like mine on a cool climate it holds pretty well.It's not to compare a $19 MUFE pencil, that's not a good on-point comparison. For its performance, price point,variety of shades and versatility, I have a winner here.