This is a fabulous orange brown on my highly pigmented lips and with a nude lipgloss gives me the most amazing warm lipcolor which goes with any make up look. This perfectly meets my need for that warm brown nude lip that is so beautiful on all woc and I had explored so many pencils and combos in my quest to achieve the look. Its alive as opposed to the flat look you get with beige based lipcolor. Thanks Nyx.Nyx lipliners are rich in pigment and apply easy on the lips with a smooth texture. I highly recommend nyx cocoa for all woc. Give it a try.

Bought this after the review below as MAC Cream O' spice is a HG lip liner for me, I use it daily to even out my lips and then apply gloss or lip balm. Unfortunately on me this color was darker than the MAC one and had more Red/brown tones in it. I Prefered Natural, which, on my lips is more similar to MAC Cream O'spice, only slightly lighter with more pink in it.

This is very close as the MAC's Cream O' Spice. It's a bit darker. It lasts and it only costs $0.69! Glad that I found the replacement!