This is a decent lip pencil, especially for the price! The colour is more pink than nude, so if you are looking for a deeper colour, this isn't the shade for you. It is nice for me as I am very pale with quite pink undertones, but keep this in mind if you are darker in skin tone. I use this pencil underneath most of my lip products as it is very close to my natural lip shade. It is slightly dry, but I prefer this over a softer pencil as they last longer in my experience. It is very pigmented, so you don't need to keep drawing over and over again, which would wear out the pencil faster. This makes it a very budget-friendly option. The smell is pretty standard. It just smells like a normal pencil, either for the lips or for paper!It doesn't stop feathering with liquid formulas, but with drier/matte lipsticks it works well. I have definite issues with feathering, however, so if you don't suffer from this irritating problem then this pencil should work fine for you!