These pencils are a fantastic formulation. I have several and I use them all over my lips as a matte lipstick and they last all day without any drying BUT this specific shade is a bust. The name is misleading it's a cool toned pastel bubblegum pink, not rose. Great formula but misleading labelling.

I am not a moron who can't sharpen a pencil. I swear.Every time I buy any kind of liner lip, eye, or brow when it comes time to sharpen the pencils they just get mangled. Every. Goddam. Time. (And I am an artist. I know how to sharpen a pencil!!)This was beautiful color and a creamy, long-wearing formula. Too bad I ended up mashing the tips and sharpening the outside wood into a point instead.F this. Buying retractable liners from now on, even though they are stupid-expensive.

LOVE LOVE LOVE if you are thinking of buying this lipliner do it! This lipliner is very versatile. I wear it with a gloss, alone as a lipstick, but my favorite has to be with a nude lipstick. This lipliner with Wet N Wild's Bare it all lipstick creates a gorgeous combo and with MAC's Myth lipstick it is the most gorgeous pink. You must buy!! I will repurchase over and over!!

With lip liners like this on the market, I'll never spend money on high end liners. This one goes great with my pink lipsticks like Viva Glam Gaga I.

Out of the NYX lip liners I have tried, this is definitely the creamiest. It's a nice base for the pink shades of lipsticks/lipglosses I have. This shade is quite warm toned and it's a colour that I find to be quite universally flattering. I would repurchase this.