I want to love the jumbo eyeshadow pencils because they're such a nifty idea. They apply well, and I love the colors (this is a springy green with a little bit of shimmer to it). But, I can't use the ES pencils because the color just does not stay put. They go on easy (takes a couple applications), but after about 4 hours the color has migrated to the outer rim of my eye, leaving a skin colored patch in the middle (this is with UDPP applied underneath!). They also tend to fade on me. I'm really sad these don't work since they're so affordable...but that's the tragedy of having oily skin :(