I think some people might have this product confused and think that it is a lipstick. I'm kind of surprised by the bad reviews but it's interesting that two people can have such a different experience! I'm glad there are a million products out there so we can all find something we like. Onto my review...When I heard NYX had lip stains, I couldn't resist picking up a few colors that I don't already own in another brand. I grabbed Victorian, Obsessed, Heartbreaker, Fresh, and Slay. Victorian is the first one that I tried and is the one that I'm wearing in the photo I uploaded above. This is watery and VERY pigmented. I got a little bit outside of my lipline, but that's an error in my application and not feathering from the product. This dried in about a minute and it hasn't budged since. I've put vaseline on top to give a little shine to my lips, and I've been drinking out of a straw all day and there's no transfer on the straw. I've eaten twice and it hasn't moved. Color me impressed! I can't wait to try the other colors. I don't know how this is going to come off if it didn't come off with Vaseline... that's my only concern lol. Update: I've added pictures of Slay, Heartbreaker, Obsessed, and Fresh. Heartbreaker and Slay are my favorites. The best way to wash these off is with soap and water. Baby oil took off like 10% of it and then did nothing. Love these!

I regularly use Nyx lipsticks, so I was quite excited to see this new option. It does not moisturize the lips, so if your lips are like mine, you'll need a gloss on top.

It wears off quickly, and it will stain your teeth if you get it on there. I may return it if I can find my receipt.

so, i think what i need to accept about this product is that it's not a normal liquid lipstick. it's very watery and is a stain (i got a red color and it was a bit jarring to apply. looked looked blood). my first application with this was awful. i tried again, and the trick is to have a consistent amount of product on the applicator. the hardest part is to get the edge to look good and have enough product to coat it evenly. you also will likely need more than one coat. if it won't dry down all the way or you want to speed the process, use translucent powder on your finger to set it. once it's dry, it stays on pretty well

I picked up this product in the color "Fresh" which is a deep berry color. The product is a thinner gloss, but not watery. I was able to apply it in one swipe for both top and bottom lips with decent coverage. I did do a 2nd coat just to amp up the color. It dried to a matte finish and was very pretty.That's where the fun ended. Apparently I am allergic to something in the product and got a stinging/burning sensation on my lips. Removal was a nightmare. I used MAC Cleansing Oil, coconut oil, micelar water, and plain old soap and water and NOTHING would completely remove the product. I had to take an allergy pill and ride it out.Even then, this stuff wore down to a stain and hung on for a good 8 hours.If it hadn't been for the reaction, I'd have given it 5 lippies.

Stained beautifully on my hand, so I was excited to try but...this is the worst lip stain I've ever used! So bad I returned to get my $7 back. Tried this every way possible but it was patchy and would set then look like total crap. HORRIBLE